Annals
of the M.B.C. - vol. 1° - n° 2 - September 1988
THE USE OF A "CIRCULAR DIAGRAW IN THE EVALUATION OF THE
BURN PATIENT'S OXYGENATION STATE
Benigno A., Marichy J.*, Lanza V.**
Divisione di Chirurgia Plastica e
Terapia delle Ustioni, 0spedale Civico, LISL 58, Palermo, Italia
* Hôpital Edouard Herriot, Lyon, France
** Casa di Cura Buccheri e La Ferla FBF, Palermo
SUMMARY.
A circular diagram (Lanza 1984) was used to study the oxygenation state of I I patients
with extensive bums (18% to 90% BSA, UBS from 42 to 270) admitted to the Edouard Herriot
Hospital Burns Centre in Lyons. The patients were divided into three groups and three
blood samples were taken from each patient in the first three weeks. Three circular
diagrams were obtained, for each group, by tabulating the mean values of the parameters
monitored, which were: PO.5, S25, SVO2, PVO2, SaO2, PaO2, T, PHv,
PHa, PvCO2, Hb, CaO2, CaO2 (S25).
Examination of the diagrams revealed the repetition, in the three groups, of a single
model, regardless of the varying gravity of the patients (the only exception is
represented in the graph based on the parameters of sample A in Group 3).
Characteristic features are:
1) leftward shift of Hb curve
2) venous phase of O2 metabolism more or less tending to scarce peripheral utilization
3) increase in T.
It may thus be concluded that the bum patient presents impairment of O2 metabolism
at tissue and pulmonary level which, though not severe enough to cause the patient's
death, plays a negative role in a more general picture of organic pathology.
Introduction
Pulmonary
complications are very frequent in the acute bum patient, occurring not only as a
consequence of the inhalation of toxic substances but also in patients not presenting
evident signs of damage due to inhalation (7).
It is possible that further research into O2 transport and metabolism
may influence prognosis and therapy in such patients.
We therefore decided that determination of the oxygenation
state would be a useful parameter to monitor during the course of the bum illness, in
order to follow its evolution more closely and to initiate as quickly as possible the most
appropriate therapy.
The
isolated study of parameters such as PaO2 and SaO2 give only partial data because they usually make it possible to
know the capacity of the blood transport of O2 without, however, indicating the possibility of peripheral loss
or tissue extraction, which are linked with the affinity of Hb for O2.
There have, in fact, been conflicting
results with regard to the study of the haemoglobin dissociation curve in the acute burn
patient: while Arturson found a shift to the right in this curve (1), Greenberg described
a shift to the left, as a result of an increase of haemoglobin affinity for O2.
In view of the difficulties of carrying out the standard
methods of PO.5 measurement, and in the hope of obtaining more complete information, we
decided to use in the burn patient the "circular diagram" proposed by Lanza in
1984 (6), which permits the monitoring of 14 tabulated parameters, using a relatively
simple method, in such a way as to produce an easily readable visual representation.
The base circumference is made up of the parameters of the
normal individual (Fig. 1).
Of the 14 parameters considered, 3 are new formulations, namely:
S25 : Hb saturation at a PO2 of 25 mm Hg which is critical for the nervous tissue. It indicates the
quantity of O2 (compared
to the total O2 available in arterial blood) still linked to the
Hb and which cannot therefore be used by cerebral tissue (3);
CaO2 (S25): This is the result of the introduction of S25 into CaO2. It expresses the value
of the constant of transported O2 taking into account the affinity of Hb for O2 (a shift to the right or
left of the Hb dissociation curve increases or decreases the availability of O2 in the tissue for equal
CaO2 levels);
T:
This expresses the time constant of an exponential function of growth by which the
phenomenon of pulmonary oxygenation is evaluated. T expresses the tendency of the O2 in the lung-blood system towards exchange, and it is particularly
sensitive to the shunt effect.
Material and
methods
The study was carried out on 11
patients (1 woman, 10 men) aged between 24 and 54 years admitted to the Burn Centre at the
H6pital Edouard Herriot, Lyons. Their burns ranged between 18% and 90% of body area (UBS
between 42 and 270) (Tab. 1).
|
Grp. 1
UBS 0-100 |
Grp. 2
UBS100-150 |
Grp. 3
UBS > 150 |
No.Patients |
4 |
3 |
4 |
Av. Age |
38
±15.21 |
40.3
±0.58 |
31.5
±6.56 |
Av. UBS |
65.2
±25.78 |
116.7
±12.58 |
230
±39.16 |
Av. BSA |
38.2
±17.29 |
41.7
±2.88 |
68.7
±15.48 |
No. Deaths |
1 |
1 |
3 |
|
Tab. 1 - Data of patients in the
three groups. |
|
On the
basis of the UBS the patients were divided into 3 groups:
GROUP 1
4 patients with UBS between 0 and 100. Average age 38 years (+/- 17.29). UBS average
65.2 (+/- 25.79).
GROUP 2
3 patients with UBS between 100 and 150. Average burn percentage 41.7 (+/- 2.88). UBS
average 116.7 (+/- 12.58).
GROUP 3
4 patients with UBS above 150. Average age 31 * 5 years (+/- 6.56). Average burn
percentage 68.7 (+/- 15.48). UBS average 230 (+/- 39.16).
The
patients in the three groups were followed up (when possible) for 3 weeks. Each patient
had blood removed within 5 days of admission (A) and again in the 2nd (B) and 3rd (C) week
after the burn lesion.
The study was carried out on arterial blood samples and on venous blood taken from the
right atrium in order to evaluate the 14 parameters (PO.5, S25, SVO2, SaO2, PVO2, PaO2, PvCO2, PaCO2, PHv, PHa, Hb, CaO2H, CaO2 (S25), T) which appear in the diagram.
Circular diagrams were made for each group of patients. These were derived from the
average of the parameter values obtained for corresponding tests.
The following equipment was used:
-
Apparatus for measuring PO2, PCO2 pH (ABL 1 Radiometer)
- Tonometer with bain-marie thermostatically fixed at 37 'C provided with electrode for PO2
- IL Co-Oxyineter 282
- Personal Computer
Results
Study of
the diagrams made with the values of the base blood samples in the three groups shows: in
all three a leftward shift of the haemoglobin dissociation curve ana consequently an
increase in S25; a more appreciable reduction of Hb in group 3 with a reduction of CaO2H and CaO2 (S25), this last
depending on the increase in S25.
The increase in PaO2 in group 3 is due to the fact that from the beginning 3 patients had to
be ventilated.
It is interesting to
note that while in groups 1 and 2 there was an increase in T, an SvO2 with a value falling on
the base circumference or slightly outside it, and a PV02 almost equal to normal values,
in group 3 T was only just outside the base circumference (statistically significant
datum: P< 0,0 1) while SvO2 and PvO2 were clearly within the circle.
With regard to the
subsequent diagrams it can be said that their appearance was similar in all three groups,
i.e. the leftward shift of the haemoglobin dissociation curve persisted in all three
groups in the second week, together with the increase in S25 and a tissue phase
characterized by slightly increased SVO2 levels at normal PvO2 levels.
There were no
particular variations in the third week except an increase in SVO2 and PVO2 in allthree groups.
There was however a different behaviour of T in groups 1 and 2 compared to group 3. In the
first two groups an initial lengthening of T was followed by a tendency to shortening,
while in group 3 T was almost normal in the first test, with a tendency to increase from
the first to the third week (Tab 2) (Fig.2-10).
Discussion
The most striking
aspect of the above results is the repetition in all three groups of the same model
regardless of the different degrees of gravity of the patients examined.
The only exception is in the diagram for the first test on the most acute patients. This
diagram seems the most favourable for the patients. A comparison between it and the
corresponding diagrams for patients with less extensive bums shows:
Experimental
studies on dogs have shown that after administration of sodium nitroprussiate and of
nitroglycerine T tends to increase while the administration of vasopressin shortens T, as
a result, respectively, of an increase or a drop in the shunt effect (4, 5)
It could iherefore be hypothesized that the lengthening of T in the patients in groups 1
and 2 may be connected to an increase of the capillary shunt following phenomena of
interstitial oedema and atelectasis, while the normal T in group 3 may be due in the more
acute patients to a redistribution in the pulmonary circulation caused by
vasoconstriction. This condition, by reducing the shunt effect, might mask a pulmonary
situation analogous to that of the other groups; with regard to this, the good venous
extraction would also confirm centralization of the circulation.
In the subsequent tests there is a progressive increase in T, which reaches the highest
levels of the three groups; in groups 1 and 2 it tends instead to shorten.
It would therefore seem that the first diagram of group 3, far from being the best, may
conceal a haemodynamic condition connected with the shock phase.
It would be hazardous to draw any definite conclusions, considering the limited number of
patients examined, but we believe that the use of this diagram makes it possible to
monitor data relative to the oxygenation state of the acute burn patient by providing a
visual representation which correlates all parameters both of the transport phase and O2 tissue utilization, and the pulmonary condition at the time.
We are thus of the opinion that the use of this method in larger number of patients with a
greater range of conditions may be recommended because, if our considerations are valid,
the circular diagram could prove extremely useful.
RESUME. On
a étudié l'état d'oxygénation en se servant d'un diagramme circulaire (Lanza 1984)
chez I I patients pr6sentant des brûlures sur 18% ~ 90% du corps (UBS de 42 A 270)
hospitalisés an Centre des Brûlés de I'Hôpital Edouard Herriot de Lyon. Sur les
malades, répartis en 3 groupes, on a pratiqué trois prélévements au cours des trois
premieres semaines Thospitalisation. Trois diagrammes circulaires ont été obtenus en
passant A la tabulatrice les valeurs moyermes des paramétres qui sont: PO.5, S25, SVO2, PVO2, SaO2, PaO2, T, PHv, PHa, PvCO2, Hb, CaO2, CaO2 (S25).
L'étude des diagrammes a mis en évidence la répétition, chez les 3 groupes, d'un meme
modéle indépendamment de la gravité des malades pris en considération (seule
exception, le graphique dérivant des paramétres du prélévement A du troisiéme
groupe).
Les caractéristiques principales en sont:
a) déplacement A gauche de la courbe de I'Hb
b) phase veineuse du metabolisme de O2 tendant plus ou moins A une faible utilisation périphérique
c) augmentation de T.
On pent donc conclure que le brûlé présente une altération du métabolisme de O2 au niveau. du tissu et
des poumons, pas au point de causer la mort du patient mais suffisante pour s'insérer
négativement dans un cadre plus vaste de pathologie de l'organisme.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
- Arturson G.: Oxygen affinity
of blood in vivo and under standard conditions in patients with severe bums. Burns 1,
249-253, 1975.
- Greenberg A.G., Frank H. and Peskin G.W.: The left-shifted
oxyhaemoglobin curve in the burn patient. J. Trauma 16, 573-578, 1976.
Lanza V. et al.:
Valutazione degli spostamenti della curva P02/SO
nel calcolo del contenuto e del flusso arterioso d'ossigeno mediante determinazione della
S25. Res. Medicae, n. 3 MayJune 1980.
Lanza V. et al.: Variazioni delle pressioni mesenteriche
durante somministrazione di nitroprussiato di sodio. Acta Anaesth. Italica vol. 32, n. 5,
1981.
Lanza V. et al.: Correction of unfavorable effects of
vasopressin by nitroglycerin infusion. Can. Anaesth. Soc. J. vol. 29, n. 3, 243, 1982.
Lanza V. et al.: A visual representation of a model for
monitoring the state of oxygenation in the critically ill patient. Acta Anaesth. Belg. 35,
suppl., 179-186, 1984.
Robinson T.J., Bubna-Kasteliz B., Stranc M.F.: Alterations
in pulmonary ventilation and blood gases in acute bums. Br. J. of Plast, Surg. 25,
250-260, 1972.
|