Annals of
Burns and Fire Disasters - vol. XIII - n. 2 - June 2000
THE SYSTEM OF ACTIVE SURGICAL MANAGEMENT OF SEVERELY BURNED
PATIENTS WITH DEEP BURNS AND COMBINED INJURIES (BURN AND BLOOD LOSS)
Atyasov N. L.
The Republican Burns Centre, Mordovia, Saransk, Russia
SUMMARY.
Purpose-oriented infusion therapy and intensive treatment proved to be successful in
restoring skin coverage in a cohort of over 3000 severely burned patients prior to the
development of irreversible changes. Owing to the enhancement of the body's defensive
mechanisms it became possible: to shorten the period of wound cleansing of necrotic
tissues; to accelerate the local treatment of wounds in the presence of daily dressings in
the pre-operative period and speed up the healing of donor sites by means of improved
reparative processes; to shorten the time gap between repeated surgical operations, thus
achieving a maximum overall gain in time, which was extremely important for the patient's
recovery; to minimize the detrimental effect of autoinununization on graft take by
reducing the number of repeated surgical interventions (in the presence of infusions that
increase in volume up to a maximum level, as the patient's state improves); and to prevent
the increasing threat of peri-operative shock by performing preventive infusions under
pressure at the most traumatic moments. It was found opportune to cover the wounds with
large-sized, closely adjoining skin flaps, a procedure that yielded better functional and
cosmetic results and helped to restrict indications of allogenic and meshed grafts. The
system was developed in fifty-two dissertation papers, and its implementation in clinical
practice helped to save the lives of patients previously regarded as doomed to die.
The twofold
decline in the mortality rate in the early stages of the burn disease achieved in the past
few years has had an insignificant impact on the overall mortality rate in patients with
deep and extensive skin injuries (IIIb-IV degree, over 30% BSA). At present such patients
are mostly observed to die - not in the first days post-burn but after a long-term period
- of the burn disease known as septicaemia, death being caused by irreversible changes in
the internal organs or by visceral and other severe complications.
The main reason for this is an excessively prolonged conservative therapy course and
inactive surgical intervention. This sets up a vicious circle in which the progressive
exacerbation of the patient's state aggravates the prospects of plastic surgery, and thus
post-operative healing of wounds in donor sites and graft take. Unsuccessful surgery
contributes to the severity of the patient's condition and may cause death at some stage
of reconstructive surgery. As soon as we became aware of the detrimental effects that such
"delaying tactics" may have, we developed a new system for the active surgical
management of severely burned patients (authorship licence N 58173, 1966) which
"opened up a new era in combustionology" (T.Y. Aryey, 1966). The system obtained
the approval of the Presidium of the Scientific Board, of the Ministry of Health Care,
RSFSR (1969), and of some research forums held in our country and abroad. The developed
system was awarded a bronze V13NH medal (1970) and a VDNH diploma in Ukraine (1987), and
it received a state prize from the Republic of Mordovia (1994).
Initial implementation of the system showed that it should be accompanied by general
intensive infusion therapy, with due attention to the patient's cardiac activity. Active
surgery enabled us to overcome the otherwise unavoidable irTeversible changes in the
patient or to halt their development.
Transfusions of blood and its components and of purpose-oriented blood substitutes
appeared to be indispensable not only as a means of combating early anaemia in burn
diseases, as is commonly thought, but also as an efficient means of preventing the
emaciation of the patient as an after-effect of the burn injury that may occur in the
septicaemia period. We obtained reliable evidence of the expediency of fibrinolylic blood
and plasma transfusions.
Repeated transfusions proved to be most indispensable in the pre-operative phase, the
recovery period following skin grafting, and during the healing period of donor sites
The premature cessation of transfusions appeared to impair the patient's condition and to
protract the final stage of operative management; not infrequently it led to destruction
of incorporated skin grafts
In cases where access to the subcutaneous veins was impeded, transfusions were performed
in the venous channels of bones or in the liver through the rechannelized umbilical vein.
We thus took into account the beneficial effects of the microvascular channels, which may
act as "biological filters".
Our system of active surgical management was successfully tested by the burns centres in
Nizimy Novgorod (prior to 1972) and in the Republic of Nordovia (1973-98) in the 3000
severely burned patients involved in the trials. It should be emphasized that its
implementation was accompanied by intensive infusiontransfusion therapy.
The resulting significant enhancement of the body's defensive mechanisms and the revival
of reparative processes led to spontaneous cleansing of the wound surfaces from necrotic
scabs in a shorter period (two weeks less - a significant time-saving) in the presence of
conservative, preserving therapeutic treatment. As a result, indications for traumatic
early incisions and scab necrolysis - which are known for their drawbacks - have become
more restricted in their application. Some authors continue to offer indications for these
traumatic techniques, which they regard as active surgical measures. They are evidently
unaware of the fact that a system of active surgical management in many cases makes their
application unnecessary.
The local preparation of actively granulating wounds for subsequent plastic surgery, as
also complication~free healing of donor sites, is also observed to take less time
Thorough local treatment of wounds in the presence of daily dressings has been seen to
accelerate granulation processes, rendering unnecessary - in most cases - the
time-consuming fixation of skin flaps to one another and to wound borders by means of
noose sutures. The flaps, split down to half their thickness by dermatomes. appear to lose
their contractile abilities owing to the absence of elastic fibres, and they adhere well
to the granulation areas. These procedures have made it possible to shorten by a
proportion of two to three times the duration of each repeated operation, so indispensable
in extensive burns, which in turn reduced the patient's exposure to narcosis.
The reliable and complication-free healing of donor sites within a short-term period
enabled us for the first time in our clinical practice to shorten the time intervals
between skin-grafting stages by as much as three to five times (in up to 5-7 days), and in
this way we succeeded in gaining a maximum overall reduction in time - previously
unattainable and so beneficial for our patients' recovery.
With a view to minimizing the detrimental effects of the autoimmunization that is observed
to progress with each successive skin graft and to impair the quality of take (the process
can even destroy the grafts), we set ourselves the research objective of ensuring that the
decreased number of surgical interventions (optimal number, three or four) had a
beneficial effect. This proved to be correct, becoming possible when we initiated repeated
transfusions, gradually increasing in volume after each successful surgical operation.
The increasing high risk of peri-operative shock, even in the presence of rational general
anaesthesia, was observed to lessen after the initiation of a methodology of preventive
fractional infusions that was developed by our team for the most traumatic phases of
surgical procedures. Infusions of this kind have to be performed together with routine
infusions.
Our active surgical strategy, with a rational use of donor site grafts, enabled us to
provide all-round continuous coverage of even extensive granulating wounds with large
split-skin grafts located close to each other, with better functional and cosmetic
results.
This appeared to offer an opportunity for restricting indications for the use of meshed
skin grafts in plastic surgery in cases of local deep burns without good reason, as also
the use of allogenic skin grafts.
Despite the fact that meshed skin grafts (resembling a drag-net) provide coverage in
larger areas of burn wounds (with a two- or three-fold increase) and adhere reliably even
in areas with immature granulation thanks to their good drainage capability (they also
adapt well to the uneven surface of the wound bed), such grafts proved to be inferior to
intact grafts because of their functional and cosmetic characteristics.
The reported system of active surgical management has proved to be efficient in restoring
skin (up to 60-70% 13SA) in extensive deep lesions, using the body's own resources. Recent
enthusiasm related to the use ot laboratory -grown culture-cultivated allofibroblasts for
the coverage of granulating wounds of insignificant extent areas seems hardly justified.
The technique we have developed is highly effective, it does not require any high~cost
equipment, and it can be applied in the average surgical unit. There is reliable evidence
that it drastically reduces the mortality rate in cohorts of comparable patients as
regards the severity of their condition. Many patients previously regarded as doomed were
seen to recover; the treatment period was two or three times shorter; the disability rate
among convalescent patients was seen to go down; and the functional and cosmetic results
turned out to be better. It should also be noted that the implementation of our
system did not entail any considerable expenditure on infusion solutions, antibacterial
drugs, or other medicines.
Our technique has had a considerable socio-economic effect. Its cost-effectiveness was
equivalent to 1.2 million roubles annually owing to the shortening of the therapeutic
course alone, according to the estimates of the medical staff in 60 burns centres in
Russia in the time period 1970-1975.
Our system helped to eliminate specific odour and blue pyesis infection, which has become
a major threat in burns centres throughout the world.
In-depth research has been and is still being carried out in our clinic's experimental
laboratory, the aim of which is to increase the efficacy of our technique in the treatment
of combined injuries (burns complicated by blood loss), which have lately tended to
increase in number owing to natural disasters, major calamities, and local military
conflicts. This research work is part of a series of all-Russian purpose-oriented
scientific programmes.
The research data have demonstrated the highly effective beneficial effects of our system
of active surgical management in trials using test animals (dogs).
In the course of our research work, observations were made on bone-marrow blood formation,
acid-alkali balance, water-electrolyte balance,cardiac activity, haemostasis,
haemo- and lymphodynamics, the lung system, liver function, the kidneys, the pancreas, and
the DVS-syndrome. Our investigation has provided us. with an in-depth knowledge
of the pathogenesis of combined injuries and stimulated the development of efficient
therapeutic methods of treatment.
The reported system of intensive therapy in severe burns was successfully applied in the
burns centre at Chelyabinsk for the treatment of persons injured in a railway accident
that occurred in Bashkiria in 1989. The system aroused interest among Russian and foreign
experts and health-care authorities from the Ministry of Health Care. On the proposal of
the Health Care Minister A.I. Potapov, the Presidium of the Scientific Board of this
Ministry took the decision on 12 September 1989 to set up a Centre of Disaster Medicine in
Saransk, the capital of Mordovia.
The development and subsequent implementation of the intensive therapy system in clinical
practice has stimulated research work: 52 dissertation theses for the Candidate of
Medicine degree and 8 for that of Doctor of Medicine have been successfully discussed.
Eight regional inter-republican conferences were held on this issue in Saransk in 1974,
1975, 1976, 1978, 1981, 1984, 1985, and 1996 (the proceedings of the Conferences have been
published). In 1972 a fundamental monograph entitled The System of Active Surgical
Management of Severely Burnt Patients (528 pp.) was issued. This volume, written on
the request of the Ministry of Health Care (16 August 1968), was highly praised by
distinguished scientists in reviews published in Clinical Surgery, 6 (1973), Kazan
Medical Journal, 6 (1973), Orthopaedics, Traumatology and Prothesis, 12 (1973),
Surgical News, 1 (1974), Surgery, 2 (1974), and Military Medical Journal,
7 (1975). The monograph has become a manual for daily use among burns experts and
other clinicians involved in burns treatment.
Various monographs have been published on this issue in the past few years, including Management
of Burn Wounds, which was presented at the International Book Exhibition in Moscow in
1979 and later reprinted by the Gulab Vasirani Publishing House in India.
Active surgical management of extensive deep burns and combined injuries aroused interest
among the participants in research forums in Russia, the CIS countries, Havana (1974),
Sofia (1976, 1980, 1984, 1992, 1993), Prague (1989, 1993), Budapest (1990), Barcelona
(1991), Tel-Aviv (1991, 1994), Berlin (1992), Paris (1994), Innsbruck (1994), Jerusalem
(1995), Verona (1995), Kosbitse (1995), Ottawa (1997), and Cairo (1997). Some of our
publications have been reprinted in Chinese journals (Surgery, 2 (1956) and 3
(1957)) and in the USA (Transfusiology, 3 (1968).
The Mordovian Republican Burns Centre has been transformed into a Clinical Research Centre
of Thermal Pathology, which has become affiliated to the Sklifosovsky Moscow Research
Institute of Emergency Medicine. All these initiatives have opened up new prospects for
the promotion of experimental and clinical research in the field of burns pathology and
combined injuries.
RESUME. Les
Auteurs ont trouvé que la thérapie infusive et le traitement intensif fonctionnalisés
sont utiles dans la restauration de la couverture cutanée dans une série de plus de 3000
grands brûlés avant le développement de modifications irreversibles. A cause de
l'amélioration des mécanismes défensifs du corps, ils ont trouvé qui'il est possible:
de réduire la période du nettoyage des lésions dans les tissus nécrotiques;
d'accelérer le traitement local des lésions en présence de médications quotidiennees
dans la période préopératoire et de réduire les temps de la guérison des sites
donneurs à la suite des procès améliorés de la réparation; de réduire les
intervalles entre les opérations chirurgicales répétées, pour obtenir une réduction
complessive optimale du temps nécessaire, ce qui est extrêmement important pour la
guérison du patient; de minimiser l'effet préjudiciable de l'autoimmunisation sur la
prise de la greffe en réduisant le numéro des opérations chirurgicales répétées avec
des infusions de volume qui augmente jusqu'à un maximum à mesure que les conditions du
patient s'améliorent; de prévenir le danger potentiel du choc périopératoire en
effectuant des infusions préventives sous pression dans les moments les plus
traumatiques. L'Auteur a eu la possibilité de recouvrir les lésions avec des lambeaux de
grosses dimensions qui si unissent en manière très adhérente; cette procédure donne
des résultats fonctionnels et cosmétiques meilleurs et tend à limiter les indications
pour les greffes allogéniques et à maille. Ce système a été développé dans 52
présentations de dissertations et sa réalisation dans la pratique clinique a contribué
à sauver la vie de certains patients précédemment condannés à la mort.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
(dissertation papers)
- Abramova S.V.: Acid-base condition of blood
at an early restorative period in acute blood loss combined with burns. Saransk, p.
17,1997
- Anoshkin l.A.: Local changes in bone tissue
following intraosscous drip-injections of blood and drugs. Chelyabinsk, p. 12, 1972.
- Aralbaev T.A.: Burn disease in mountainous
areas and the principles of infusion therapy. Moscow, p. 21, 1986.
- Atyasov N.I: Intraosseous infusions in
traumatology and orthopaedics. Gorky, p. 33, 1965.
- Begoulov N.I: Efficacy of blood-restitution
methods in combined injuries (burn and acute blood loss). Minsk, p. 20, 1986.
- Belyacv AX: Ways of improving infusion
therapy in combined injuries (burn and blood loss). N. Novgorod, p. 30, 1996.
- Bril E.V.: The effect of narcosis on
cholinesterase activity in burn patients in the septicaemia period. Kharkov, p. 22, 1982.
- Bugrova K.P.: General anaesthesia in active
surgical tactics in burn patients. Moscow, p. 17, 1969.
- Vereshagina E.S.: Clinicophysiological
grounding for the methodology of operative management in severe chest burns in paediatric
patients. Gorky, p. 16, 1988.
- Gasin.I.K.: Acid-base balance and oxygen
depot in blood in the management of combined injuries with volecam and
ozonotherapy.Saransk, p. 16, 1988.
- Galustov G.N.: Pilot study of active
surgical management in burn patients in Checheno-Ingushetia. Chelyabinsk, p. 21, 1976.
- Gorbunov S.N.: Acid-alkaline balance of
blood and outer breath in the pre-operative period and inhalatory narcosis. Gorky, p.
18,1975.
- Guzeev V.A.: Transfusion therapy in severe
burns. Alma-Ata, p. 48,1971.
- Denisov V.M.: Transfusion of cadaver blood
to patients with extensive, deep burns. Orenburg, p. 18, 1967.
- Dmitriev G.I: Reconstructive-restorative
surgery in rehabilitation of patients with burns sequelae. Perm, p. 32, 1986.
- Eliseeva L.P.: Fluid- and
electrolyte-balance at an early restorative period in acute blood loss and burns. Saransk,
p. 17, 1998.
- Ionicheva L.V.: Adaptive abilities of the
haemopoietic system at an early restorative period in deep burns and blood loss. Saransk,
p.not communicated, 1999.
- Karpushin A.A.: Acid-alkaline balance of
blood in burn injury and its dynamics in complex management of burn disease. Moscow,CITO,
p. 16, 1971.
- Kildyushov AX: Haemostatic disorders at an
early restorative period in burns complicated by acute blood loss. Saransk, p. 17,1994.
- Kiselyev S1: The role of donor skin grafts
in the choice of rational surgical management in severely burned patients. Ryazan, p.
17,1971.
- Klevtsova TX: The functional state of the
cardiovascular system 42 in burn patients. Leningrad, VMOLA, p. 15, 1988.
- Korablyov S.B.: Pilot study of autoimmune
responses and their influence on graft take in repeated skin autoplasty. Kujbishev, p. 21,
1982.
- Kotlov I.S.: Intrahepatic circulation and
some hepatic functions in burns complicated by blood loss - various ways of its
restitution. Gorky, p. 20, 1986.
- Krizhanovskaya N.A.: Changes in the
peripheral blood and bone marrow blood formation in patients with deep burns - the effect
of intensive transfusion therapy. Moscow, p. 21, 1972.
- Kupriyanova B.A.: Antibacterial treatment
of granulating wounds in burns patients in the pre-amodermatoplastic period. Chelyabinsk,
p. 15, 1972.
- Kupriyanova T.S.: Aerosol treatment of burn
wounds with antibacterial drugs. Ivanovo, p. 22, 1975.
- Lazarev V.A.: Pathogenic grounding of
regional (intra-umbilical) infusion-transfusion therapy in severely burned patients.
Moscow, p. 33, 1988.
- Levin S.A.: Haemocoagulatory properties and
clinical use of plasma and blood platelets from cadaver blood. Moscow, p. 3, 1997.
- Liyaskina A.V.: Study of the haemopoictic
system at an early restorative period in deep burns complicated by blood loss. Saransk, p.
21, 1999.
- Matchin E.N: Active surgical management of
deep burns in Donskaya City Hospital, Tulskaya Region. Ryazan, p. 17, 1975.
- Matchin EX: Ways of improving the surgical
treatment of severelyburned patients. Moscow, p. 36, 1997.
- Makhrov V1: Lymphodynamics and biochemical
changes in blood and lymph and various ways of blood restitution in burns complicated by
blood loss. Chelyabinsk, p. 19, 1986.
- Ogoltsova V.A.: Clinico-morphologic results
of skin restoration with meshed grafts in severely burned patients. Kharkov, p. 16, 1982.
- Okunev N.A.: Renal function in burns
complicated by acute blood loss - various ways of its restitution. Chelyabinsk, p. 18,
1985.
- Pakhomov S.P.: Active surgical management
of extensive deep burns. Moscow, p. 19, 1977.
- Ponomaryeva N.A.: Methodology and
functional outcomes of therapy in deep burns of shoulder joints. YaroslavI, p. 18, 1968.
- Pilaeva S.I.: Dynamics of the data in
nonspecific immunological reactivity in burn diseases. Gorky, p. 19, 1972.
- Ryazantsev E.V.: Correction of acute kidney
failure at an early restorative stage in burns complicated by blood loss (a pilot study).
Saransk, p. 20, 1995.
- Saushev I.V.: Disorders in transcapillary
exchange of fluid and in lung surfactant activity in burns complicated by acute blood loss
- some ways of their correction. Saransk, p. 19, 1995.
- Semyonov A.V.: Corrections of disorders in
acid-base balance of blood with sodium oxybutyrate and dimephosphone in burns complicated
by blood loss. Saransk, p. 21, 1998.
- Sovo E.R.: Prevention of operational shock
in burns patients by active surgical management. Chelyabinsk, p. 15, 1969.
- Sokolov LX: Early free skin grafting in
deep burns. Gorky, p. 12, 1964.
- Tarasova L.F.: Haernotransfusional therapy
in children suffering from burn exhaustion. Ivanovo, p. 14, 1972.
- Taratinov I.B.: Disorders in haemostasis
system and their correction in combined injuries. Saransk, p. 20, 1996.
- Tyukin A.A.: Experimental grounding and
clinical experience in necrolysis of deep wounds. Gorky, p. 34 1973.
- Tyagusheva M.N.: The use of spongy
substance of bone tissue as a biological microfilter. Saransk, p. 16, 1997.
- Usanova A.A.: Phase analysis of cardiac
activity and some data relating to central haemodynamics in burns complicated by blood
loss. Saransk, p. 11, 1994.
- Utkina I.V.: Functional and morphological
changes in kidneys and their correction in combined injury. Saransk, p. 21, 1999.
- Chistyakov S.l.: Changes in proteolytic
activity of blood in burns complicated by blood loss - some ways of their correction. N.
Novgorod, p. 17, 1991. Sheremetyev J.A.: Pathogenic role of proteolytic enzymes in the
development of early burn anaemia - ways of its correction. Moscow, p. 20, 1980.
- Shifrina G.A.: Functional state of the
heart in burn patients.Ivanovo, p. 17, 1974.
- Yakushev S.A.: Pilot study of active
surgical management of burn patients in a city hospital. Smolensk, p. 18, 1974.
This
paper was received on 22 November
1999.Address
correspondence to: Dr N.I. Atyasov, B. Khmelnitskogo Street 44-7, Saransk, Russia, 430000.
|
|