Annals Of the MBC - vol. 3 - n' 4 - December 1990

BACTERIOPHAGE THERAPY OF PSEUDOMONAS BURN WOUND SEPSIS

Abul-Hassan H.S., El-Tahan k Massoud B., Gomaa R.

Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery Unit and Bacteriology Department, Faculty of Medicine, Alexandria, Egypt


SUMMARY. Phage therapy was used to control Pseudomonas aerugmosa infection in 30 cases of resistant infections in patients with bum areas ranging from 10-25%. Post-phage cultures showed absence of organisms in 12 patients and their presence in 18. Satisfactory graft take was present in 18 cases only and inferior take in 12 cases. It is not practical to use this technique on a wide scale and it should be restricted to cases with strains resistant to available antibiotics.

Introduction

Bacterlophages can be used to distinguish bacteria on the basis of the particular phage or phages to which they are susceptible. These phages are able to kill bacteria and at the same time they are harmless to man. Attempts were therefore made to use them to treat bacterial infections. However the great variety of phage-specific strains of bacteria within a species and the rapidity with which phage-resistant forms develop are important limiting factors (1).

The aim of this study is to evaluate the efficacy of bacteriophage therapy in cases of pseudomonal infection of the burn wound, since Pseudomonas aeruginosa is one of the most resistant organisms for antibiotics.

Materials and methods

Thirty cases of documented pseudomonas burn wound sepsis were treated by phage. These cases showed resistant Pseudomonas infection to all available antibiotics and chemotherapeutic agents.
The patients were 18 males and 12 females; six were children below the age of nine and the remaining cases had an age range from 18-54 years. The burned surface area ranged from 10-21%.
Swabs were taken from the burned areas and cases which showed resistant Pseudomonas infection were selected for our study. Antibiotics were stopped locally and systemically for 48 hours before swabbing.
Phage stock containing a high number of phages acting specifically on the strains of Pseudomonas originally isolated from the bum wound was prepared to be applied locally on the burn wound. The number of phages/ml stock was calculated according to Miles and Misra (2) to confirm that the phage stock contained a large number of phages (more than 1010/ml). Gauze soaked in phage was applied 3 times per day for each patient.
Assessment of phage application was made by temperature recording, observation of the general look of the patient, the local condition of the raw area and percent of graft take. Another swab was taken at the end of phage therapy.

Results

The application of the phage was needed for 5-7 days in almost 50% of the cases (15-21 dressings) (Tab. 1).
Eight cases showed sterile cultures after these applications and 7 cases positive for Pseudomonas aeruginosa with no control of infection by the phage (Tab. 2).
Tab. 3 demonstrates the amount of discharge, which stopped in 12 cases only, diminished in another 12 and was not affected in the others.
The granulation tissue showed improved criteria and decrease in oedema, a fiery red color, minimal discharge in 15 cases, slight improvement in 9 cases and no effect in 6 cases (Tab. 4).
Graft take was evaluated above 90% in 6 cases, from 60-70% in 12 cases and below 30% in 12 cases (Tab. 5).

Discussion

The bacteriophages constitute a group of viruses which have various cocci, bacilli and vibrios as their specific hosts. They are found naturally in places where bacteria exist, e.g. the intestines of man, animals, insects, sewage and soil. Their presence can be demonstrated by the lytic action they produce in susceptible bacteria during active growth. They are highly specific agents acting only against one bacterial species or type or a few related types (3).
The ability of bacterial viruses to lyse and kill bacterial cells led to the hope that they would be therapeutically effective in bacterial infections. Many trials have been performed with variable results (4).
Since phages (like all viruses) multiply only within living cells, and since their size precludes direct observation except with the electron microscope, it is necessary to follow their activity by indirect means. For this purpose, advantage is taken of the fact that one phage particle introduced into a crowded layer of dividing bacteria on a nutrient agar plate will produce a more or less clear zone of lysis in the opaque film of bacterial growth. This zone of lysis is called a .. plaque; it results from the fact that the initially infected host cell bursts (lyses) and liberates dozens of new phage particles, which then infect neighbouring cells. This process is repeated cyclically until bacterial growth on the plate ceases as a result of exhaustion of nutrients and accumulation of toxic products. When handled properly, each phage particle produces one plaque; any material containing phage can thus be titrated by making suitable dilution and plating measured samples with an excess of sensitive bacteria. The plaque count is analogous to the colony for bacterial titration (5).
Pseudomonas aeruginosa, which is the most important and dangerous bacterium in burn sepsis and septicaemia, shows variable incidences. Sarsoor (6) found an average of 19.5% which is raised to 26% during hospitalization, and still has a high incidence in burns of the lower half of the body, and full-thickness burns (7). A high incidence was reportedby Thompson (53%) (8) and Ramirez (42%) (9).

Case
No.

Age
(years)

Extent of Burn

Duration of Phage Application

Number of Dressings

1

3

17

7

21

2

7

10

5

25

3

9

25

14

40

4

12

20

7

20

5

3

15

17

51

6

2   1/2

5

5

15

7

5

7

14

40

8

18

20

17

50

9

30

15

7

21

10

35

18

10

30

11

3

5

7

22

12

14

10

5

13

13

20

19

14

50

14

8

3

7

21

15

19

12

15

42

16

30

20

6

19

17

9

10

12

35

18

7

5

13

35

19

2

5

8

22

20

5   1/2

7

9

25

21

to

12

8

21

22

3

4

6

18

23

7

9

12

24

24

9

10

5

15

25

18

20

14

42

26

20

10

7

21

27

31

14

13

39

28

2

3

6

18

29

9

7

12

36

30

15

12

15

45

Table 1 - Showing age, extent, duration of application and number of dressings in each case

 

  Number of Cases
Positive Cultures 12
Negative Cultures 18
Total 30
Table 2 - Results of post-phage cultures

 

Discharge Number of Cases
Stopped 12
Diminished 12
No Effect 6
Total 30

Table 3 - Effect of phage on the amount of discharge

 

 

Number of Cases

Improved 15
Slight Improvement 9
No Improvement 6
Total 30

Table 4 - Effect of phage on raw areas

 

  Number of Cases
Excellent (>90%) 6
Good (60-70%) 12
Poor (<30%) 12
Total 30

Table 5 - Effect of phage on take of skin grafts

Within this study phage therapy was attempted in 30 cases of pseudomonal infection. Although quantitation of the organism was not done, which is a drawback, assessment was achieved by observing the discharge, the condition of the raw area, post-phage culture, and graft take. Thus the evaluation is a rough but a useful one.
The discharge stopped in 12 cases only, diminished in 12 patients, and there was no effect in the remaining 6 cases. This explains the improvement in the general condition in only 12 patients.
Significant improvement of the raw areas was seen in half of the patients and slight improvement in 9, with no effect in the remaining 6 cases. This shows that phage application has a good effect on the condition of the burn wound through its antibacterial power.
The goal in dealing with a bum wound is a successful graft take, and if we consider graft take as a major and important parameter for evaluation, we have 18 cases with good results within a reasonable period of time. The remaining 12 cases have shown inferior results, since the graft take was below 30%. This clearly shows that phage application had satisfactory results, especially for this resistant form of organism. This was found in spite of the fact that the post-phage cultures were negative in 12 and positive in 18 patients. The explanation for this result is that phage application controlled infection in 12 cases and diminished the bacterial count of this organism. Therefore, bacterial count (quantitative estimation) is necessary for verification of this finding (10).
We can conclude that phage application to the infection, but it is rather impractical since it is not always available, it is expensive and it takes a long time to prepare a phage stock, during which time new strains or other organisms may invade the bum wound. For these reasons, we recommend it for cases which are resistant to available antibiotics (4).

P.B.R.A. has a role in combating

RÉSUMÉ. La phagothérapie a été utilisée pour contrôller l'infection par Pseudomonas aeruginosa dans 30 cas d'infection résistantes chez des patients avec une surface corporelle brûlée de 10-25%. Les cultures effectuées après le traitement avec les bactériophages ont indiqué l'absence d'organismes avec les bactériophages chez 12 patients et leur présence chez 18. Il y avait une prise satifaisante de la greffe dans seulement 18 cas et inférieure dans 12 cas. Cette thérapie n'est pas donc une méthode pratique pour utiliser sur une grande échelle et il faut s'en servir seulement dans les cas résistants aux antibiotiques disponibles.


BIBLIOGRAPHY

  1. Mourad A.S.: "Virology for Medical Students", 46-58, The General Egyptian Book Organization, Alexandria, 1976.
  2. Miles A.A. Misra S.S.: The estimation of the bacterial power of the blood. J. Hyg., 10, 38: 732, 1938.
  3. El-Ghoroury A.A. Lackany A.S., Mazloum H.A., Abbas A.M.A.: "Principles of Medical Microbiology", 60, Dar El-Maaref, Cairo, 1972.
  4. Massound B.K., Talaat M., Omar N.Y., Lackany H.S.: Bacteriophage phage therapy of chronic Pseudomonas aeruginosa infection of the ear. J. Egypt Publ. Health Assoc. (under publication).
  5. Jawez E., Meinick J. L., Adelberg E. A.: "Medical Microbiology", 211, Ilth ed., Lang Medical Publication, California, 1974.
  6. Sarsoor A. K.: The Microbial Pattern of the Burned Wound. M. Ch. Thesis, Univ. Alexandria, Fac. Medicine, 1980.
  7. Nagwa B.Z.: Role of faecal Pseudomonas aeruginosa in post-bum infection in the Main Alexandria University Hospital Burn Unit. M. Ch. Thesis, Univ. Alexandria, Fac. Medicine, 1982.
  8. Thompson M.: The Bums Unit in Copenhagen. Time of onset and duration of infection. Scand. J. Pl. Rec. Surg., 4: 61, 1970.
  9. Ramirez A.T., Melendres F.X, Capii C.A.: Pseudomonas resistance to gentamyeine. Scand. J. Pl. Rec. Surg., 13: 69-71, 1979.
  10. El-Tahan AX, El-Beheiry A.S., Massoud B., Gornaa R.: Evaluation of bacteriophage therapy in bum wound sepsis. Bull. Alex. Fac. Med., 4: 964-971, 1983.



 

Contact Us
mbcpa@medbc.com