Annals of Burns and Fire Disasters - vol. IX - n. 1 - March 1996
OUR EXPERIENCE IN THE TREATMENT OF PATIENTS WITH
SELF-INFLICTED BURNS
Bocchi A., Toschi S., Caleff i E., Papadia F.
Division of Plastic Surgery, University of Parma,
Italy
SUMMARY.
Self-inflicted burns represent a great problem because they are often deep and extensive,
and the patients generally have a history of mental illness and difficult family
relations. The authors describe the benefits of appropriate psychological and psychiatric
support for these patients.
Introduction
Self-inflicted bums represent a
problem of great complexity for the plastic surgeon for the following reasons:
- In most cases they are extensive full-thickness lesions.
They are often flame burns, and the lack of "success" of the self-inflicted
injury is usually due to chance and early aid.
- Most of the hospitalized patients have a history of mental
ilness, alchoholism or drug abuse, which makes the prognosis worse. They seldom or never
collaborate during therapy.
- Family support, so important from the psychological
viewpoint, is often lacking because most of the patients live in affective isolation.
Material and methods
Between 1988 and 1992 eight patients
with self-inflicted bums were admitted to our Burn Unit, equivalent to 1.8% of the total
number of bum patients (438).
Patient |
Sex |
Age
(yr) |
TBSA
(%) |
Sites
of lesion |
Previous
attempts |
Previous
diseases |
Result |
1 |
f |
45 |
35 |
trunk/limbs |
yes |
psych. illness |
death |
2 |
f |
57 |
15 |
trunk/limbs |
yes |
psych.illness |
survival |
3 |
m |
24 |
50 |
face/trunk/limbs |
no |
psych. illness
alcoholism |
death |
4 |
m |
50 |
30 |
face/trunk/hands |
no |
- |
survival |
5 |
m |
28 |
70 |
trunk/limbs/genitalia |
yes |
psych. illness
|
death |
6 |
m |
68 |
40 |
head/neck/trunk |
no |
psych. illness
|
survival |
7 |
f |
40 |
100 |
total body |
yes |
psych. illness
|
death |
8 |
m |
40 |
40 |
trunk/limbs |
no |
psych. illness
alcoholism |
death |
|
Table I - The patients treated |
|
This figure is lower than the average
percentage described in the literature. There were however 11 other patients in whom
attempted suicide was suspected on the basis of the clinical history (4.3% of the total).
In all eight patients the injury was caused by flame (while in the group of 11 two
patients were burned by boiling water).
Six of the eight patients (75%) died, from 1 to 75 days after injury. In seven cases the
patients had a history of mental illness, were under treatment with psychotropic drugs or
were hospitalized in a psychiatric ward.
The extent of the bum varied from 15 to 100%. Some patients tried to explain their
attempted suicide as a desire to expiate a fault or to follow their religious beliefs.
Five patients had previously attempted suicide.
The local and general bum therapy followed our habitual protocol, with the following
additional measures:
- Treatment with psychotropic drugs under psychiatric
control.
- Hydrotherapy and medication with the support of a
psychiatrist, to give the patient adequate clinical and psychological support.
- Contact with the patient's family in order to give
information about the patient's health and to invite them to visit him.
Results and discussion
The psychiatric and,psychological support
helped to create a certain degree of collaboration in five patients and it was possible to
dress them without the psychiatrist's support.
It was more difficult to get collaboration from the family, who in some cases promised to
take care of the patient but did not in fact do so.
The high incidence of mortality is due to the extent of the lesions, and to the advanced
age and previous diseases of some of the patients, as shown in Table 1.
Conclusion
The average mortality rate in
self-inflicted burn patients is higher than that in patients comparable for age, depth and
burn extent who did not attempt suicide. The previous diseases, the wish to die and the
lack of collaboration make the prognosis worse.
Psychiatric and psychological support helps to maintain the patient quiet and to
facilitate the work of the physicians and nurses.
RESUME. Les
brûlures infligées volontairement à soi-même représentent un grand problème parce
qu'elles sont souvent profondes et étendues, et les patients ont généralement une
histoire de maladies mentales et de rapports difficiles avec leur famille. Les auteurs
décrivent les avantages d'un support psychologique et psychiatrique approprié pour ces
patients.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
- Bassetto F., Banon D., Matano P., Baldo M.,
Silvestri A.: 11 fuoco come mezzo d'autosoppressione. Atti 37' Congresso Società Italiana
di Chirurgia Plastica, Genova, 1988.
- Davidson T.I., Brown L.C.: Self-inflicted burns:
a 5 years retrospective study. Bums, 11: 157, 1985.
- Klasen H.J., Van der Tempel G.L., Heckert J. et
al.: Attempted suicide by means of burns. Burns, 15: 37, 1989.
- Lochaitis A., Iliopoulou E., Parker J.M.,
Poniros N., Panayotaki D.: Burns as a result of violence and self-inflicted injury. Ann.
Medit. Burns Club, 4: 219-221, 1991.
This paper was
presented at the 7th MBC Meeting
in Perpignan, France, in December 1993.
Address correspondence to: Dr A. Bocchi
Divisione di Chirurgia Plastica, Ospedale di Parma
Via Gramsci 14 43 100 Parma, Italy. |
NEUVIEME CONGRES DU
CLUB MEDITERRANEEN POUR LES BRULURES
ET LES DESASTRES D'INCENDIE (MBC)
28 mai - 1 juin 1996
Tunis (Tunisie)
Thèmes principaux: Brûlures et
Prévention des Désastres d'Incendie
Organisé par la Société Tunisienne de Chirurgie Plastique
Reconstructice Maxillo-faciale et Esthétique
Secrétariat scientifique: Service de Chirurgie Plastique
Hôpital Aziza Othmana
Place de la Kasbah 1008 Tunis, Tunisie
Tel.: 216-1-663-638, 216-1-663-640
Fax: 216-1-563-971 |
NINTH MEETING OF THE
MEDITERRANEAN CLUB
FOR BURNS AND FIRE DISASTERS (MBC)
28 May - 1 June 1996
Tunis (Tunisia)
Main Topics: Bums and the Prevention of
Fire Disasters
Organized by the Tunisian Society of Plastic Reconstructive
Maxillo-Facial and Aesthetic Surgery
Scientific secretariat: Service de Chirurgie Plastique
Hôpital Aziza Othmana
Place de la Kasbah 1008 Tunis, Tunisia
Tel.: 216-1-663-638, 216-1-663-640
Fax: 216-1-563-971 |
|