|Annals of Burns and Fire Disaslers -Vol. IX - n. 2 - June 1996
ADDITION OF ANTIOXIDANTS AND POLYETHYLENE GLYCOL 4000 ENHANCES THE HEALING PROPERTY OF HONEY IN BURNS
Department of Surgery, Dr. Vaishampayan Memorial Medical College, Solapur, Maharashtra, India
SUMMARY. A prospective study was carried out in two groups of 42 randomly allocated patients with partial-thickness burns to compare the effect of honey alone with that of honey fortified with antioxidants (vitamin C and vitamin E) and polyethylene glycol (PEG) 4000. Bums treated with honey plus antioxidants and PEG healed earlier than those treated with honey alone (mean 6.4 (lays versus 8.3). In this study the addition of antioxidants and PEG 4000 accelerated the healing properties of honey in burns.
Honey has been popular as a wound
dressing since ancient times. It has been found to be useful in the healing of bum wounds.
1-4 The viscous barrier that honey presents to wound invasion by micro-organisms and to
fluid loss is an important factor in rendering the burn wound sterile and preventing
colonization. It must however be realized that honey is not and never will be a
well-defined product.'.' Various factors, e.g. type of bee and plant species involved,
influence the effectiveness of different honeys.
Patients and methods
Eighty-four patients with
partial-thickness bums in less than 40% BSA were treated in our Unit in the period January
1993 to June 1994. After initial management, patients were assigned randomly to two
groups. In group I patients (N' = 42) pure, unprocessed undiluted honey obtained from
beehives was applied (15-30 ml) over the burn area, after washing with normal saline, and
covered with pads and bandages. In group 2 patient,, (N' = 42) the same batch of honey as
used in group I was applied together with vitamin C, vitamin E and PEG over the burn area
in the same quantity. For this purpose, 300 ing of vitainin C, 400 mg of vitamin E
(alpha-tocopherol-acetate) and I nit of' 25% PEG 4000 (Abbott Laboratories, Illinois, USA)
was added to 100 g of honey. The quanti(y of PEG 4000 added to the honey was fixed
on a trial -aind-error basis in order to make the mixture semisolid or oiniment-like. The
wounds were covered with an absorbent dressing. In both groups the dressing was changed on
day 2 and if there was no evidence of infection this was repeated on alternate days until
the wound healed. Bacterial culture and sensitivity determinations were performed in all
wounds on admission and on days 8 and 21 in all cases or until wound healing. The time
taken for complete healing was noted in both groups and the data were analysed using the
Of the 84 patients, 61 were male in(] 23 fenialc, The youngest patient was 2 years old anti the oldest W. llSA area ranged from 10 to 35% (mean 17.6%) ill group J and from 11 to 40% (mean 18.2%) in group 2. Table I shows possibly by protecting the tissues from the cytotoxic effects of lipid peroxidation.
In patients treated with honey alone, healthy granulation appeared in the majority of cases after about one week: wounds healed by day 10 days in 20 patients and by day 15 in another 12 patients. Thus 32 patients (76. 1 %) achieved wound healing by day 15 (mean 8.3 days).
In patients treated with honey plus, granulation appeared by day 4 in the majority of cases, with wounds healing by day 6 in 34 patients and by day 9 in another 8 patients (mean 6.4 days) (Table II). The time taken for wound healing differed significantly between the two groups (p <0.001).
The results of culture swab study are shown in Table III. The organisms isolated in 26 infected patients in both groups on day 8 were: Staphylococcus aureus coagulasepositive (8 Patients), Pseudomonas aeruginosa (4), Klebsiella (5), Escherichia coli (5) and Proteus (4).
There was no bleeding during dressing changes, and no difficulty in removing dressings in either group. Overgranulation was found in group 1, with minor contracture in two cases; in group 2 there was no overgranulation and only one contracture. Allergy or other side-effects such as renal failure were not observed in any patient in either group.
Honey is a mixture of sugars prepared by bees from natural sugar solutions (nectar) obtained from flowers. The nectar collected by bees is deposited in honeycombs. By inverting the sucrose in the nectar, bees increase the density of honey, making it a thick, sweet energy food. Pure unboiled honey is composed of 40% fructose, 20% water and 40% glucose. It contain,., various minerals inagnesium and calcium), acids acctic acid), vitamins, and enzymes (diastase, invertase, olucose oxidase and catalasc).
Topical application of' honey has been observed to be effective in ulcers, infected wounds, and burns. Herbal extracts added to honey may contain antioxidants and polyunsaturated fatty acids.' These antioxidants are needed for cell protection against reactive oxygen species, as described by Friedel et if." in lbeir expeninewal sHidics on thermal trauma. A high cell ~ktitioxi(Ltiit conceniration after thermal injury theoretically should help the cell prolection. Vitamin C, an antioxidant willi sliglil pro-oxidant activity, and vitamin E are good for fflis purposc.
Polyethylene glycol (PEG) 4000 is a macromolecule which has been added to honey and pollen extract for the treatment of test lesions in the cow.' It has also been used to reduce peritoneal adhesions ill experimental animals. The proposed mode of action ofthe macromolecule is by promotion of non-adherent healing through polymer coating or siliconization of the injured surface." On the basis of this proposed mode of action, PEG 4000 was added to honey and antioxidants.
PEG 4000 is known to have toxic effects.Toxicity due to absorption of PEG in burn patients treated with PEG-based cream, resulting in renal failure, has been reported.` However, in the present study, no toxic effects were observed in any patient, possibly owiug to the reduced concentration and quantify used.
In this prospective study, burn wounds treated with honey fortified with vitamin C, vitaniin E and PEG 4000 healed more rapidly than wounds. treated with honey alone. As already said, this may be due to llie non-adliercin healing property of PEG and llic action of' (lie antioxidants,
RESUME. L'auteur a effectué une étude prospective dans deux groupes de 42 patients atteints de brûlures d'épaisseur partielle, distribués au hasard, pour comparer l'effet du miel seul à celui du miel fortifié avec des antioxydants (vitamine C et vitamine E) et le glycol polyéthylène (PEG) 4000. Les brûlures traitées avec le miel intégré avec antioxydants et PEG ont guéri plus rapidement (lue celles traitées avec le seul miel (valeur moyenne 6,4 jours contre 8,3). Selon les résultats de cette étude, l'addition des antioxydants et de PEG a accéléré les propriétés curatives du miel dans les brûlures.